基于事故树方法的城市灰霾的致因机理分析：以天津市为例

doi:10.11949/j.issn.0438-1157.20171045

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

近年来，以PM_2.5为特征的灰霾天气已成为中国许多城市极其严重的环境污染问题，对大气质量和人体健康具有严重的不良影响。由于煤炭在我国能源结构中占据主导地位，燃煤废气可能是导致灰霾污染的其中一个非常关键的影响因素。要进行大气污染防治，首先要对大气污染物的来源和致因机理进行研究。拟从系统方法论的新角度出发，以京津翼地区其中的代表城市天津为研究案例，探索将经典实用的事故树方法（FTA）应用在燃煤与灰霾的致因机理以及风险因子管理的新问题上。通过识别和辨明导致燃煤废气大量排放的直接和潜在原因，构建了“灰霾天气-燃煤废气过量排放”的事故树，基于最小割集、结构重要度、概率重要度以及临界重要度分析，定性、定量地评价了关键风险因子/事件对灰霾天气的贡献和影响。分析结果表明，能源结构不合理，没有合适可替代的清洁能源导致煤的大量燃烧是影响最大的关键风险因子。本工作可为灰霾天气的致因机理分析，风险因子防控以及管理提供一套科学有效的新思路和方法。

关键词: 灰霾, 煤燃烧, 污染, 系统工程, 可持续性

Abstract:

Haze weather characterized by PM_2.5 has become a serious environmental pollution problem in major Chinese cities recently, which has bad effect on the air quality and human health. Coal burning may be one of the critical factors of haze pollution because coal is the most important energy source in China. It is significant to figure out the pollutant sources and causation mechanism of urban haze to indicate directions and support theoretical basis for the atmospheric pollution prevention and control. Based on a new perspective of systematic methodology, the fault tree analysis (FTA) method is employed and investigated for the causation mechanism analysis and risk management of urban haze related to coal burning for Tianjin in this work. All of the important risk factors are discussed and identified by using this deductive FTA method. After the fault tree “haze weather-excess emission of coal-fired exhausts” is established, the qualitative and quantitative assessments based on the minimal cut sets, the structure, probability and critical importance degree analysis of those risk factors in the fault tree system are also carried out for Tianjin city. The analysis results show that “unreasonable energy structure” and “without sustainable cleaner energy” are the most important risk factors for causing excess coal burning. This study may provide a new scientific and effective tool/strategy for the causation mechanism analysis and risk management of haze pollution in China.

Key words: haze, coal burning, pollution, systems engineering, sustainability

中图分类号:

TQ021.8

黄卫清, 徐平如, 钱宇. 基于事故树方法的城市灰霾的致因机理分析：以天津市为例[J]. 化工学报, 2018, 69(3): 982-991.

HUANG Weiqing, XU Pingru, QIAN Yu. Causation mechanism analysis of urban haze based on FTA method: taking Tianjin as a case study[J]. CIESC Journal, 2018, 69(3): 982-991.

参考文献 34

[1]	HUANG G. PM2.5 opened a door to public participation addressing environmental challenges in China[J]. Environ. Pollut., 2015, 197:313-315.
[2]	ZHANG R, JING J, TAO J, et al. Chemical characterizations and source apportionment of PM2.5 in Beijing:seasonal perspective[J]. Atmos. Chem. Phys., 2013, 13:7053-7074.
[3]	LI M, ZHANG L. Haze in China:current and future challenges[J]. Environ. Pollut., 2014, 189:85-86.
[4]	ZHANG Y, CAO F. Is it time to tackle PM2.5 air pollutions in China from biomass-burning emissions?[J]. Environ. Pollut., 2015, 202:217-219.
[5]	ZHOU X, CAO Z, MA Y, et al. Concentrations, correlations and chemical species of PM2.5/PM10 based on published data in China:potential implications for the revised particulate standard[J]. Chemosphere, 2016, 144:518-526.
[6]	LI H, YANG S, ZHANG J, QIAN, Y. Coal-based synthetic natural gas (SNG) for municipal heating in China:analysis of haze pollutants and greenhouse gases (GHGs) emissions[J]. J. Clean. Prod., 2016, 112:1350-1359.
[7]	ZHOU S, YANG L, GAO R, et al. A comparison study of carbonaceous aerosols in a typical North China Plain urban atmosphere:seasonal variability, sources and implications to haze formation[J]. Atmos. Environ., 2017, 149:95-103.
[8]	GAO J, WOODWARD A, VARDOULAKIS S, et al. Haze, public health and mitigation measures in China:a review of the current evidence for further policy response[J]. Sci. Total. Environ., 2017, 578:148-157.
[9]	FU H, CHEN J. Formation, features and controlling strategies of severe haze-fog pollutions in China[J]. Sci. Total. Environ., 2017, 578:121-138.
[10]	LIU G, YANG Z, CHEN B, et al. Prevention and control policy analysis for energy-related regional pollution management in China[J]. Appl. Energy, 2016, 166:292-300.
[11]	GAO M, GUTTIKUNDA S K, CARMICHAEL G R, et al. Health impacts and economic losses assessment of the 2013 severe haze event in Beijing area[J]. Sci. Total. Environ., 2015, 511:553-561.
[12]	ZHANG Q, QUAN J, TIE X, et al. Effects of meteorology and secondary particle formation on visibility during heavy haze events in Beijing, China[J]. Sci. Total Environ., 2015, 502:578-584.
[13]	TIE X, ZHANG Q, HE H, et al. A budget analysis of the formation of haze in Beijing[J]. Atmos. Environ., 2015, 100:25-36.
[14]	YANG Y, LIU X, QU Y, et al. Formation mechanism of continuous extreme haze episodes in the megacity Beijing, China, in January 2013[J]. Atmos. Res., 2015, 5:192-203.
[15]	HUANG R, ZHANG Y, BOZZETTI C, et al. High secondary aerosol contribution to particulate pollution during haze events in China[J]. Nature, 2014, 514:218-222.
[16]	HUANG W Q, FAN H B, QIU Y F, et al. Application of fault tree approach for the causation mechanism of urban haze in Beijing-considering the risk events related with exhausts of coal combustion[J]. Sci. Total Environ., 2016, 544:1128-1135.
[17]	HUANG W Q, FAN H B, QIU Y F, et al. Causation mechanism analysis for haze pollution related to vehicle emission in Guangzhou, China by employing the fault tree approach[J]. Chemosphere, 2016, 151:9-16.
[18]	ESCHER B I, FENNER K. Recent advances in environmental risk assessment of transformation products[J]. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2011, 45:3835-3847.
[19]	SEXTON K. Cumulative health risk assessment:finding new ideas and escaping from the old ones[J]. Hum. Ecol. Risk. Assess., 2015, 21:934-951.
[20]	TSANG M P, BATES M E, MADISON M, et al. Benefits and risks of emerging technologies:integrating life cycle assessment and decision analysis to assess lumber treatment alternatives[J]. Environ. Sci. Technol., 2014, 48:11543-11550.
[21]	BEDFORD T, COOKE R. Probabilistic Risk Analysis:Foundations and Methods[M]. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2001.
[22]	PLACCA L, KOUTA R. Fault tree analysis for PEM fuel cell degradation process modeling[J]. Int. J. Hydrogen. Energ., 2011, 36:393-405.
[23]	CHENG S, LI Z, MANG H, et al. Application of fault tree approach for technical assessment of small-sized biogas systems in Nepal[J]. Appl. Energy, 2014, 113:1372-1381.
[24]	LINDHE A, NORBERG T, ROSEN L. Approximate dynamic fault tree calculations for modelling water supply risks[J]. Reliab. Eng. Syst. Safe., 2012, 106:61-71.
[25]	ABDUL R F, VARUTTAMASENI A, KINTNER-MEYER M, et al. Application of fault tree analysis for customer reliability assessment of a distribution power system[J]. Reliab. Eng. Syst. Safe., 2013, 111:76-85.
[26]	唐桂忠, 张广明, 巩建鸣. 基于模糊粗糙集和事例推理的凝汽器真空故障诊断[J].化工学报, 2011, 62(8):2227-2231. TANG G Z, ZHANG G M, GONG J M. A new method of fault diagnosis of condenser vacuum based on fuzzy rough set and case-based reasoning[J]. CIESC Journal, 2011, 62(8):2227-2231.
[27]	姜周曙, 翁翔彬, 王剑, 等. 反渗透海水淡化系统"脱盐率与产水量下降故障树"分析[J]. 化工学报, 2014, 65(6):2172-2178. JIANG Z S, WENG X B, WANG J, et al. Fault tree analysis on decreases of desalination rate and permeate flow rate of seawater reverse osmosis desalination system[J]. CIESC Journal, 2014, 65(6):2172-2178.
[28]	黄卫清, 李秀喜, 钱宇. 含滞后及不确定参数动态过程系统的定量优化方法与应用[J]. 化工学报, 2009, 60(1):83-89. HUANG W Q, LI X X, QIAN Y. Quantitative optimization method and application of dynamic process systems with time delay and parametric uncertainty[J]. CIESC Journal, 2009, 60(1):83-89.
[29]	HUANG W Q, LI X X, QIAN Y, et al. Dynamic flexibility analysis of chemical reaction systems with time delay:using a modified finite element collocation method[J]. Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 2011, 89:1938-1946.
[30]	HUANG W Q, QIAN Y, SHAO Y Y, et al. Delay sensitivity analysis for typical reactor systems with flexibility consideration[J]. 2014, 53:14721-14734.
[31]	中国统计局. 2015中国统计年鉴[M]. 北京:中国统计出版社, 2016. National Bureau of Statistics of China. 2015 China Statistics Yearbook[M]. Beijing:China Statistics Press, 2016.
[32]	天津市统计局. 2015天津统计年鉴[M]. 北京:中国统计出版社, 2016. Tianjin Municipal Bureau of Statistics. 2015 Tianjin Statistical Yearbook[M]. Beijing:China Statistics Press, China, 2016.
[33]	中国国务院. 大气污染防治计划[EB/OL]. http://www.gov.cn/zwgk/2013-09/12/content_2486773.htm, 2013-09-10. China's State Council. Action Plan on Prevention and Control of Air Pollution[EB/OL]. http://www.gov.cn/zwgk/2013-09/12/content_2486773.htm, 2013-09-10.
[34]	NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council)[R]. Report of the Coal Use Contribution to China's Air Pollution. Beijing, 2014.